Construction disputes

UK construction contracts: who bears ground condition risk?

Published on 19 November 2026

Clear risk allocation, informed tendering and contractual discipline shape the scope for recovering additional costs

Crane detail in front of a skyscraper

At a glance

  • The Uniform decision reinforces the importance of express risk allocation. Tender information and early clarification help contractors assess uncertainties before pricing.

  • Following the agreed procedures of compliance with notice and variation requirements, retained records and checks on the representative’s authority can determine whether a claim succeeds.

  • Commercially realistic risk allocation allows for meaningful site investigations and weighs risk premiums against later price adjustments.

Unforeseen ground conditions are a familiar challenge for contractors and employers. A central question is what an "experienced contractor" could reasonably be expected to anticipate and  allow for. Ground conditions remain a key focus of commercial negotiation, but have not featured heavily in reported cases.     

Earlier this year, the Privy Council considered the extent of a contractor's responsibility for unforeseen ground conditions in Uniform Building Contractors Ltd v The Water and Sewerage Authority of Trinidad and Tobago (Trinidad and Tobago) [2026]. 

The contract allocates risk

Uniform Building Contractors Ltd (UBC) was appointed by the Water and Sewage Authority of Trinidad and Tobago (WASA) following a tender process to carry out the design, supply and installation of pipeline. The parties entered into a contract for the works based on the FIDIC Yellow Book form (1999 edition). The contract expressly stated that UBC had full design responsibility and was deemed to have satisfied itself as to, among other things, the form and nature of the site and the extent of work and materials necessary to carry out the works, and that the contract price was sufficient. 

The contract was ultimately terminated by WASA and, during the accounting of the sums due for the works carried out, UBC argued that the contract had been varied to incorporate additional works as a result of unexpected ground conditions and to incorporate night working. The parties had not followed the formal variation process in the contract.  

The contract provided that any claim must be brought within 28 days of the date UBC became (or should have become) aware of the circumstances giving rise to the claim. UBC had not made any formal claim for these alleged variations at the time. Nevertheless, it argued that the engineer had waived these procedural requirements on WASA's behalf. It also argued that it had not been given sufficient time to carry out site investigations before starting work and that this should alter the allocation of design responsibility. 

Overruling the Court of Appeal, the Privy Council rejected UBC's claims. It found that the contract provisions on responsibility for design and ground conditions were clear that UBC was responsible for the design and delivery of the works, including how they were carried out (provided the works complied with the contract).   

If UBC considered that the works had been varied, or that it was entitled to make a claim under the contract, it should have notified WASA within 28 days, as specified in clause 20.1. 

The Privy Council rejected the argument that WASA had waived the procedural requirements in the contract. The contract did not provide the engineer with blanket authority on behalf of WASA, and it expressly stated that the engineer had no authority to waive any of UBC's obligations under the contract.

Osborne Clarke comment

The Privy Council's decision maintains the existing position. Although it does not introduce new tests, it includes useful reminders for contractors and employers seeking to manage ground condition risks. 

Contractor risks

The contract is the starting point. In a dispute, the court will look to its express terms, including the technical and pricing documents. The court will be reluctant to move away from those positions. 

Technical information provided by the employer calls for care. The inclusion of specifications or technical documents in an employer's tender pack does not mean that the employer has assumed design risk or warranted that information, particularly if the contract terms state otherwise. If the contract allocates design responsibility and/or ground risk to the contractor, it is prudent for a contractor to undertake its own due diligence. 

Clarification processes and any relevant pre-market engagement offer opportunities to resolve uncertainties. If tender documents are unclear or contain apparent discrepancies, these need to be raised as early as possible. If the contract places ground risk on the contractor, opportunities to investigate the site are particularly important. Whether the contractor is responsible for reasonably foreseeable ground conditions is an objective test. A court is unlikely to be sympathetic where a contractor has not foreseen the relevant conditions because it did not carry out appropriate due diligence. This is particularly important for contracts with public bodies, which have far less freedom than private sector organisations to agree changes to the price, contract terms or delivery approach once the deadline for submitting tenders has passed.   

Contractual procedures matter. The contract's requirements for variations or claims include formalities for written notices, timescales and limitations on the authority of the project manager or employer's representative. However, the representative may not have authority to act as the employer's agent for every purpose. 

Record-keeping and evidence are critical. Whether establishing that a ground condition is unforeseeable or that a communication with the project manager constitutes a variation, contemporaneous documents and other evidence will be critical to substantiating the position. 

Employers' choices

The scope of assessing ground conditions matters. If the contractor is expected to take ground condition risk,  a meaningful opportunity to assess the existing conditions, including carrying out site investigations, can help it realistically price the risk. A compressed tender period may leave bidders with insufficient time to carry out their investigations and reflect their findings in their tendered prices. 

Value for money depends on more than a fixed price, which may appear attractive regardless of the ground conditions. However, it may also include a significant risk premium, leading to some contractors not bidding at all. The employer may therefore pay for a risk that never materialises.  This risk will be acute in cases of "dark ground" where existing structures prevent the contractor carrying out any site investigations.   

New information on ground conditions can affect pricing. If the contractor cannot carry out site investigations until after it has been appointed, the scope for increasing the price can be increased to reflect new information. Without competitive tension, there is a risk of a bad bargain for the employer, especially where there are time pressures.  For public sector clients, there may also be procurement risks. Post-tender changes to the scope and cost of the works may, in some circumstances, expose the employer to a risk of a challenge to the contract. 

The project manager's authority has limits. The project manager may be the contractor's main point of contract, but the contract should make clear which decisions the project manager can make and which require the employer's determination. There should also be a clear process for obtaining that approval. This will help to avoid over-identification of the project manager with the employer, whether by the contractor or by the project manager itself. 

This Insight updates Osborne Clarke's 2015 analysis of the degree of foresight expected from contractors.

Angela Lovett, Associate Director at Osborne Clarke, contributed to this Insight. 

* This article is current as of the date of its publication and does not necessarily reflect the present state of the law or relevant regulation.

Connect with one of our experts

Interested in hearing more from Osborne Clarke?