The government has launched a consultation on targeted employment status reforms and additional protections for the genuinely self-employed. Creating a single status of worker remains a longer-term goal; worker and employee status would remain distinct under the current proposals.
Implementation status
- Not included in the ERA.
- The consultation closes on 8 January 2027. It concerns employment-law status, not the separate tests for tax or social security purposes. Implementation timing remains unconfirmed.
- Action
- Businesses using contractors, freelancers or gig-economy labour should review contracts and how arrangements operate in practice, including the degree of direction or control and whether substitution rights reflect reality. Even a valid substitution right would no longer necessarily prevent worker status if the proposed reforms are adopted.
- Keep clear evidence supporting status decisions in anticipation of the proposed presumption of worker status in tribunal proceedings. Consider the wider workforce implications of an adverse status ruling, particularly where colleagues work on broadly similar facts. Employment-law worker status would not, by itself, change tax treatment.
- In detail
- The consultation proposes placing less emphasis on personal service by elevating control in the limb (b) worker test. The proposed question is whether the individual personally provides services and/or is under a significant level of direction or control by the employer or engager. Significant control could therefore support worker status despite a contractual right of substitution.
- A presumption of worker status is proposed in tribunal proceedings: the business would have to demonstrate that the individual is not a worker. There would be no presumption of employee status, and the burden and standard of proof on whether the substantive right itself was breached, such as correct holiday pay, would not change.
- The consultation proposes amending the tribunal penalty regime to make repeated failures to recognise employment status an express aggravating factor. A tribunal could impose an additional penalty where a business denies limb (b) worker or employee status despite an earlier ruling that colleagues working on broadly similar facts have that status.
- Views are also sought on using the Fair Work Agency’s civil proceedings and legal assistance powers to determine status, and on an interactive online assessment providing a non-binding indication of employment status.
Protections for the genuinely self-employed
- A proposed right for certain self-employed individuals would require a written statement of key engagement terms, including the work, expected duration, payment and termination arrangements.
- The government is also exploring wider blacklisting protections, protection from detrimental treatment for taking appropriate action in response to serious and imminent workplace danger, and broader access to trade union health and safety representative roles.
- Impact
- Worker and employee status would remain distinct. Worker status alone would not confer full employee rights such as ordinary unfair dismissal protection or statutory redundancy pay. Individuals genuinely operating their own business, with the engager acting as their client or customer, could remain self-employed.
- Employment status is an area coming under increasing scrutiny in light of the gig economy and adoption of rules by European jurisdictions, such as the EU's Platform Workers Directive (which may be implemented by December 2026).
- The proposals could widen access to core worker rights and make reliance on substitution clauses more difficult. Their implications extend beyond holiday pay and minimum wage because they sit alongside reforms such as guaranteed hours and payments for shifts cancelled at short notice. The government recognises the essential role of self-employed labour but considers competitive advantage through bogus self-employment unacceptable.